How can you ensure all stakeholders are included in environmental impact assessment?
Learn from the community’s knowledge. Experts are adding insights into this AI-powered collaborative article, and you could too.
This is a new type of article that we started with the help of AI, and experts are taking it forward by sharing their thoughts directly into each section.
If you’d like to contribute, request an invite by liking or reacting to this article. Learn more
— The LinkedIn Team
Environmental impact assessment (EIA) is a process of evaluating the potential effects of a proposed project or policy on the natural and social environment. It is a key tool for ensuring sustainable development and environmental justice. However, EIA can be challenging and complex, especially when it involves multiple stakeholders with different interests, values, and perspectives. How can you ensure all stakeholders are included in environmental impact assessment and have a meaningful role in decision-making? Here are some tips to help you.
The first step in any EIA is to define the scope and objectives of the assessment, as well as the criteria and methods for evaluating the impacts. This should be done in consultation with the relevant stakeholders, such as the project proponents, regulators, affected communities, and interest groups. By engaging the stakeholders early on, you can identify their concerns, expectations, and preferences, and ensure that the EIA covers the issues that matter to them. You can also avoid potential conflicts and misunderstandings later on.
-
Bill Yock
Chief Technology and Data Officer
The project and/or policies that an EIA is measuring need to be clearly defined in order to gather stakeholder input and set clear goals and objectives. Clarity on geographic boundaries and governing ordinances will help define the scope of objectives. Defining financial impacts and objectives is important for building ROI models for green investment and budget tracking purposes.
1
Stakeholder analysis is a systematic way of identifying and categorizing the stakeholders involved in or affected by the EIA, and assessing their interests, influence, and relationships. It can help you understand who the key players are, what their needs and motivations are, how they communicate and interact, and how they might react to the EIA outcomes. Stakeholder analysis can help you design and implement appropriate strategies for engaging and involving the stakeholders throughout the EIA process, and ensure that their views and inputs are considered and balanced.
-
Bill Yock
Chief Technology and Data Officer
If Stakeholder analysis involves large populations any survey conducted should be randomly performed and sampling biases managed ethically. Demographic and cultural characteristics of stakeholders should be documented.
1
Participatory methods are techniques that enable the active involvement of stakeholders in the EIA process, such as surveys, interviews, focus groups, workshops, public hearings, and consultations. They can help you collect and analyze data, generate and evaluate alternatives, and identify and mitigate impacts. Participatory methods can also enhance the transparency, legitimacy, and credibility of the EIA process, and foster trust, collaboration, and learning among the stakeholders. However, participatory methods require careful planning, facilitation, and documentation, and should be tailored to the context, culture, and capacity of the stakeholders.
-
Bill Yock
Chief Technology and Data Officer
Content created in participatory methods may require curation and aggregation and can be enhanced using wiki and open data types of tools. Voting and decision making processes related to the content governance should be documented in transparent ways.
Social impact assessment (SIA) is a subfield of EIA that focuses on the human dimensions of environmental change, such as health, livelihoods, culture, rights, and values. SIA can help you understand how the project or policy might affect the well-being, behavior, and interactions of the stakeholders, and how they might cope or adapt to the changes. SIA can also help you identify and address the potential conflicts, risks, and opportunities that might arise from the project or policy, and ensure that the benefits and burdens are equitably distributed among the stakeholders.
The final step in any EIA is to monitor and evaluate the results of the assessment, and the implementation of the project or policy. This should be done in collaboration with the stakeholders, who can provide feedback, suggestions, and complaints, and verify the accuracy and relevance of the findings and recommendations. Monitoring and evaluation can help you measure and report on the effectiveness, efficiency, and sustainability of the EIA process, and the impacts and outcomes of the project or policy. It can also help you identify and address any gaps, errors, or unforeseen consequences, and improve the EIA practice and performance.
-
Ossama Ismail
Greater Cairo Foundries: In-house Business Consultant & Instructor
Information sources for determining EA. & EI. : 1general information documents: brochures 2 operations manuals, process flowcharts, or quality and product plans 3reports from previous audits, assessments, or reviews, 4information from other management systems 5technical data reports, published analyses or studies, or lists of toxic substances 6compliance obligations 7codes of practice, national and international policies, guidelines and programmes 8procurement data 9product specifications, product development data, DDS or energy &material balance data 10waste inventories 11monitoring data 12environmental permit or licence applications 13views of, requests from, or agreements with interested parties 14reports on emergency situations
2
-
Bill Yock
Chief Technology and Data Officer
Lifecycles of projects and timelines related to policies should be considered when defining the frequency and duration of monitoring. If measures change over time they should be noted on relevant reports and/or analytic dashboards.
-
Dr Reji Kurien Thomas
I Empower organisations as a Global Technology & Business Transformation Leader | CTO | Harvard Leader | UK House of Lord's Awardee |Fellow Royal Society & CSR Sustainability |Visionary Innovator |CCISO CISM |DBA DSc PhD
Comprehensive Stakeholder Mapping- Identify all potential stakeholders, including often overlooked groups. I recall a project where including local schools provided unique insights into community needs. Regular Consultation Meetings- Hold frequent meetings with diverse stakeholder groups. In one project, these meetings revealed crucial environmental concerns from a local fishing community. Surveys and Feedback Form-: Distribute these to gather a wide range of opinions. A survey I conducted once highlighted concerns from minority groups that were not initially considered. Public Forums and Workshops- Facilitate open discussions. Hosting a workshop helped me integrate indigenous knowledge into an environmental plan.
3
-
Ossama Ismail
Greater Cairo Foundries: In-house Business Consultant & Instructor
* Consider Also : ISO 14015 :2022 ,Environmental Due Diligence (EDD) assessment : through a systematic process of identifying 1.environmental aspects, 2.issues and 3.conditions as well as determining, if appropriate, 4.their business consequences. * Due Diligence : comprehensive, proactive process to identify the actual and potential consequences of an organization’s ) decisions & activities.
1
-
Bill Yock
Chief Technology and Data Officer
Leverage established frameworks like the UN Sustainable Development Goals to help define goals and objectives of the EIA. Look for common interests and emphasize shared goals among stakeholders to maximize impacts.