What is the most effective way to get feedback on a job description?
Learn from the community’s knowledge. Experts are adding insights into this AI-powered collaborative article, and you could too.
This is a new type of article that we started with the help of AI, and experts are taking it forward by sharing their thoughts directly into each section.
If you’d like to contribute, request an invite by liking or reacting to this article. Learn more
— The LinkedIn Team
Writing a job description is a crucial step in the hiring process, but how do you know if it is clear, accurate, and attractive to your target candidates? Getting feedback on your job description can help you improve its quality, avoid common pitfalls, and increase your chances of finding the best talent for your role. In this article, you will learn what is the most effective way to get feedback on a job description and how to implement it in your recruiting strategy.
Feedback on your job description can help you ensure that it matches the actual requirements and expectations of the role, while also highlighting the benefits and opportunities of working for your company and in your team. Additionally, it can help you avoid biased, vague, or misleading language that could deter or exclude qualified candidates. Moreover, feedback can assist in optimizing your job description for search engines and job boards to increase its visibility and reach, as well as identify and address any gaps, errors, or inconsistencies that could affect its clarity and credibility. Ultimately, by getting feedback on your job description before you publish it, you can refine and polish it to attract the best applicants.
-
Brian Miller
Feedback on your job description is crucial for multiple reasons. It ensures alignment with actual role requirements and company expectations, highlighting benefits and opportunities. Additionally, feedback helps eliminate biased or misleading language that might deter qualified candidates. Optimizing for search engines and job boards increases visibility. Identifying and addressing gaps, errors, or inconsistencies enhances clarity and credibility. Ultimately, seeking feedback before publishing refines and polishes the job description, attracting the best applicants.
3
-
Rita Tami Sambo
Talent Acquisition | People and Culture | Diversity and Inclusion | Global Recruiter | Data driven HR Management |
To get effective feedback on a job description in HR and recruiting: Involve Stakeholders: Consult hiring managers, team members, and key stakeholders. Feedback Sessions: Conduct meetings to discuss the job description openly. Use Surveys: Collect anonymous input through surveys for honest opinions. Industry Benchmarking: Compare with similar roles in the industry. Clear Communication: Ensure clarity and understanding of responsibilities. Test the Market: Share with external professionals for insights. Continuous Improvement: Encourage ongoing feedback for refinement.
3
Depending on your goals and resources, there are several sources of feedback you can tap into. Your hiring manager is the best source for understanding the role, skills, responsibilities, and expectations of the position, as well as how to align the job description with the company's culture and vision. Your colleagues can provide a perspective on the market, competition, and candidate pool, as well as any technical or industry-specific terms that need explanation or clarification. Current employees can testify to the experience and benefits of working for your company and in your team, as well as showcase your employer brand and value proposition. Lastly, target candidates can tell you what they are looking for in a job and how they perceive your job description. They can also provide feedback on the application process and communication channels. It's important to balance the quantity and quality of feedback when collecting and analyzing it in order to make the most out of these sources.
-
Brian Miller
Seek feedback from diverse sources. Your hiring manager provides insights into role expectations, skills, and cultural alignment. Colleagues offer perspectives on the market, competition, and industry terms. Current employees showcase the company's appeal and employer brand. Target candidates share their expectations and perceptions of your job description, aiding in refining the application process. Balancing quantity and quality of feedback from these sources ensures a comprehensive and valuable evaluation, optimizing your job description for success.
3
-
Suresh JV
Head Talent Acquisition - India at Genesys | LinkedIn Top Voice
Crafting a job description that resonates with top talent requires feedback from a diverse group of individuals. Below are a few whose expertize could be sought out to make a killer job description. The Hiring Manager: They're the key decision-maker and have a clear understanding of the role's requirements and expectations. Recruiters: They're experts in understanding candidate preferences and market trends, providing insights into what attracts top talent. Current Employees: They have firsthand experience with the company culture and the specific duties of the role, offering valuable insider perspectives. Potential Candidates: Their feedback can reveal any gaps or misalignments in the description.
1
When it comes to collecting feedback on a job description, there are various methods and tools you can use, such as surveys, interviews, and reviews. Surveys can be distributed online with platforms like SurveyMonkey or Google Forms to ask questions about the content, format, and tone of the job description. Interviews can be conducted one-on-one or in groups with platforms like Zoom or Skype to ask more in-depth and specific questions. Reviews can be done on online platforms such as Textio, Joblint, or Gender Decoder to get instant feedback on the language, style, and effectiveness of the job description. You can choose one or more of these methods and tools depending on your resources and goals. It is important to design and implement them in a way that is clear, consistent, and respectful of your feedback providers.
-
Brian Miller
Collecting feedback on a job description can be achieved through surveys, interviews, and reviews. Online platforms like SurveyMonkey or Google Forms facilitate survey distribution to assess content, format, and tone. Platforms like Zoom or Skype enable one-on-one or group interviews for more in-depth insights. Utilizing online tools such as Textio, Joblint, or Gender Decoder offers instant feedback on language and effectiveness. Choose methods based on your resources and goals, ensuring clear, consistent, and respectful design for effective feedback collection.
2
-
James (Jim) P. Riney
Talent Acquisition Manager @ Freese and Nichols | Engineering Recruiter
I have found that writing a job description is one of the toughest tasks for people to start in the recruiting process. As a recruiter, I try to help our hiring managers get started by giving them something to tear apart. It seems it's easier for someone to correct and build upon a draft rather than starting with a blank screen. Often, companies have official job descriptions for legal or compliance reasons. These make awful job postings, but are a good starting point. I take a few minutes to write a job posting that would be attractive to the candidate who is a fit, based on this job description, focused mainly on the job duties and requirements. I send this draft to the hiring manager, giving them permission to tear it apart.
2
Once you have collected feedback on your job description, it's important to analyze it and identify the main themes, patterns, and insights. Depending on the type and format of the data, you can use different techniques and tools for analysis, such as coding, scoring, or synthesizing. For example, you can assign codes or labels to the feedback data using software like NVivo or Atlas.ti. You can also assign scores or values to the feedback data with software like Excel or SPSS. Additionally, you can summarize and interpret the feedback data with software like Word or PowerPoint. You can choose one or more of these techniques and tools depending on the complexity and volume of the data, but it is essential to be objective, transparent, and critical in your analysis to avoid confirmation bias or cherry-picking.
-
Brian Miller
Analyzing feedback involves identifying key themes and patterns. Use techniques like coding, scoring, or synthesizing depending on data type. Tools like NVivo or Atlas.ti aid in assigning codes to feedback. Excel or SPSS can assign scores or values. Summarize and interpret data with tools like Word or PowerPoint. Be objective, transparent, and critical to avoid bias in your analysis. Choosing the right techniques and tools ensures effective interpretation, leading to valuable insights for refining your job description.
2
-
Deirdre Crawford
Principal Rec2Rec Consultant 🌎 | USA
I'm a big fan of data - and I track most of mine in Excel. I said I'm a big fan, not that i actually know how to mine, visualize, etc. I will merely ask for your opinion or do some market research, and take a tally, assessing the outcome at the end. Once you've taken note and reviewed everyone's feedback, whether it's been gathered from friends, colleagues, or surveys and forms. It's time to assess, whether are there any recurring responses, themes, or patterns, and do you wholly agree with anything particular.
Once you have analyzed the feedback on your job description, it is time to implement the changes and improvements. Depending on the nature and scope of the changes, you can use various strategies and tools to do so. Prioritizing, editing, and testing are some of the most common strategies. For prioritizing, tools such as Trello, Asana, or Jira can be used to rank items based on importance, urgency, and feasibility. Editing requires tools such as Grammarly, Hemingway, or ProWritingAid to revise the content, format, and tone of your job description. Testing involves using tools such as Google Analytics, Indeed Analytics, or LinkedIn Analytics to track performance and results. You can select one or more of these strategies and tools depending on your resources and goals. However, it is essential to be flexible in your implementation and monitor and evaluate your outcomes.
-
Peter Vegh
Hard-to-fill position specialist Europe - Senior Talent Acquisition Specialist HUNGARY AND EUROPE
Know your target group. As an engineering specialist, I follow engineers on LinkedIn, read their posts, talk to them, listen to them. No technology tool does that for me. Technology is also very important in recruitment, but there are no real shortcuts. You have to be interested in the person behind the CV.
1
-
Erin Santamaria
Talent Acquisition Advisor @ Fiserv | Full Life Cycle Recruiting & Strategic Sourcing
Over the past few months, I have had to take job postings down and revamp them. If I dont get many applicants over the week etc, thats when I need to sit back, and see how the posting can be modified by either changing the wording, titles etc.
3
-
Marcia Hancock, MPA-HC
Resume & LinkedIn Profile Writer ➜ Your Job Search Partner! ★ Cover Letters ★ Bios ★ Author ➡️ Seasoned expert in helping you create a top-notch resume and LI profile to ‘knock the socks off’ potential employers
Job Description versus Job Posting. In an ideal work world, a job description is the internal document used by HR teams, hiring managers, and employees as a role's official outline. Job descriptions are a tool to measure performance, list expectations as an employee guide to achieve 'success'. A job posting/job ad is an external document used by hiring teams in recruiting efforts. As a former HR professional, I advise my clients to ask for a copy of the job description 'JD' during the selection process. This avoids any confusion about the job's essential requirements, all qualifications, necessary experience, needed skills, expected performance criteria/evaluation, and information about the physical requirements and the work environment.
(edited)1